Prerequisites for including blogs? Feedback please.
I'm currently in the middle of tightening up some of the submission processes and have realised that it would be better to hear from you in relation to our acceptance policies. Up to this point, acceptance has been fairly relaxed and, in some ways, ad hoc.
So, I have a few ideas to throw your way and see what you think I should do with them - and I'll hopefully explain my concerns for them. Here goes;
- Gardening BLOGS only? - a BLOG is defined as, " a shared on-line journal where people can post diary entries about their personal experiences and hobbies; 'postings on a blog are usually in chronological order'". This has been my benchmark for accepting sites up until now until I hit one the other day that came from Urban Farmer Weekly a Google Sites site. While it's not a blog by definition it very closely resembles it yet it doesn't produce an RSS feed and it's articles wouldn't feature in the Picks section. Your thoughts?
- Minimum Age or Number of Posts? - should there be a pre-requisite number of posts that the blog contains before it's accepted? Or, should it be a certain age? Or should we accept any blogs regardless of either?
- Ongoing registrations? - another point to consider is should Blotanical expect a blog to produce x number of posts regularly to remain listed? I know that some bloggers have been ill and have been unable to post as regularly as when they started but there now a few blogs that are listed that haven't posted anything for at least 6 months or more.
- Blog Names? - should Blotanical continue to allow blogs to be submitted even though they share the same name with another blog already listed? Should they be separately identified somehow?
There's a few to get you started. I'm certainly not keen to make submission, or participation, too onerous but I am aware that if these things aren't at least considered on a community level then it may become distressing to some, if not all of us, in the future.
Once I've had some feedback, I'll try and compile a poll so that we can decide on some of these issues and any others that may come up through this discussion.
Thanks, in advance, for your expressions...